Can you invest without violating Ahimsa? NSE’s new index brings non-violence to India’s stock market – Firstpost


India’s stock market is getting a new kind of benchmark that looks beyond how much money a company can make and asks whether its business activities align with the principle of non-violence.

NSE Indices, a subsidiary of the National Stock Exchange, has launched the Nifty500 Ahimsa Index, a thematic benchmark designed for investors who want their equity portfolios to reflect ethical and animal-welfare considerations.

The move could mark a new phase in India’s passive investing ecosystem. While investors have long had access to conventional sectoral, factor-based and ESG indices, the Nifty500 Ahimsa Index attempts to translate a culturally rooted principle into a transparent, rules-based framework for capital markets.

STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD

The index comprises 326 companies selected from the Nifty 500 universe. Companies are screened on the basis of their products, services and business activities under the Ahimsa Investment Movement (AIM) framework developed in collaboration with the Ahimsagain Foundation.

Only companies classified in the Green category under the framework are eligible for inclusion. Companies falling under the Orange and Red categories are excluded.

From non-violence to an investible benchmark

The index is based on a relatively simple idea: investors should be able to put their money into companies without directly supporting businesses considered inconsistent with the principle of Ahimsa.

However, the challenge lies in converting a philosophical principle into an objective investment methodology.

The screening framework evaluates companies based on their business activities and their potential links to animal harm. This means the index excludes businesses that fall outside the prescribed ethical criteria, while retaining companies that meet the framework’s standards.

The result is a portfolio spread across 20 sectors, rather than a narrowly focused basket of companies.

The index is weighted according to the free-float market capitalisation of its constituents. Its top holdings include Bharti Airtel, Infosys, Mahindra & Mahindra, Tata Consultancy Services, Maruti Suzuki India, NTPC, BSE, Tata Steel, Hindalco Industries and Adani Ports and Special Economic Zone.

Why the index matters for investors

The Nifty500 Ahimsa Index is not directly investible. Its real significance will depend on whether asset managers use it to launch exchange-traded funds (ETFs), index funds and other passive investment products.

That could create a new category within India’s expanding passive investment market.

“The launch of the Nifty500 Ahimsa Index reflects the growing maturity of India’s passive investing ecosystem, where investors are increasingly seeking portfolios that align with specific values alongside financial objectives,” said Divam Sharma, Co-founder and CEO of Green Portfolio.

According to Sharma, the index’s broad sectoral representation could allow investors to pursue ethical investing without completely sacrificing market breadth.

STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD

The index includes companies from sectors such as automobiles, capital goods, information technology and financial services, among others.

“Thematic and rules-based investing is gaining traction, and benchmarks like these could see wider acceptance as more passive products are introduced,” Sharma said.

The potential market extends beyond retail investors. Family offices, institutions, the Indian diaspora and overseas investors seeking India exposure with defined ethical exclusions could also become potential users of investment products linked to the index.

A new opportunity for ETFs and index funds

The launch comes at a time when Indian investors are increasingly looking beyond traditional mutual funds and actively managed portfolios.

The growth of ETFs and index funds has made it easier for investors to construct portfolios around specific themes and investment philosophies.

The Nifty500 Ahimsa Index could give asset managers a ready-made framework to build products for investors who want ethical exclusions without having to manually study the business activities of hundreds of companies.

“Instead of manually evaluating each company’s business practices, investors now have access to an index built on the AIM framework, which has screened more than 1,100 listed companies and includes only those with no links to animal cruelty,” said Krishna Patwari, Founder and Managing Director of Wealth Wisdom India.

STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD

For investors following Jain, vegan or other ethical investment philosophies, such screening could significantly reduce the effort involved in constructing a portfolio.

Patwari said the index could become a foundation for ETFs, index funds and other passive investment products centred on the principle of Ahimsa.

The potential for such products is significant because the benchmark is drawn from the Nifty 500 universe, one of India’s broadest large- and mid-cap market segments.

The Nifty 500 represents more than 92 per cent of the free-float market capitalisation of companies listed on the NSE and over 84 per cent of traded value.

That gives the Ahimsa Index a much broader starting universe than a niche ethical fund.

Who defines Ahimsa?

The launch also raises a more fundamental question.

Can a complex philosophical principle such as Ahimsa be reduced to a fixed list of investment exclusions?

The answer may differ from investor to investor.

“I think the Nifty500 Ahimsa Index is an interesting addition because it recognises that some investors want their portfolios to reflect their non-violent values, not just their financial goals,” said Tejas Khoday, Co-founder and CEO of FYERS.

STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD

The framework excludes businesses linked to areas such as alcohol, tobacco, defence, gambling and certain activities related to animal cruelty.

But the boundaries of ethical investing are not always clear-cut.

“One person may want to exclude only alcohol and tobacco, while another may also question fossil fuels or mining,” Khoday said.

He added that even agricultural activity could raise ethical questions for some investors because farming can affect animals and insects.

“I don’t think the index claims to define Ahimsa for everyone; that would be impossible to achieve. But it’s a thoughtful initiative by NSE,” Khoday said.

That distinction could be important for the index’s future.

The Nifty500 Ahimsa Index is not claiming to offer the only interpretation of Ahimsa. Instead, it provides one transparent methodology that investors can choose to follow.

India’s version of values-based investing

The concept is not entirely new globally.

Investors around the world increasingly use screening methodologies to exclude businesses associated with alcohol, tobacco, gambling, weapons or other activities that conflict with their social, religious or ethical preferences.

STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD

India already has indices and investment products based on various philosophies.

The Nifty500 Ahimsa Index now adds a distinctly Indian ethical framework to the country’s growing universe of thematic benchmarks.

“The launch of the Nifty500 Ahimsa Index is a significant step towards broadening India’s ESG and ethical investing landscape,” said Narinder Wadhwa, Managing Director and CEO of SKI Capital Services.

Wadhwa compared the concept with Shariah-compliant investment products, which exclude businesses such as alcohol, tobacco and gambling for investors seeking to follow Islamic principles.

The Ahimsa Index, he said, could appeal to investors who want their portfolios to reflect non-violence and responsible business practices.

The broader trend is clear: investors are increasingly looking at more than just financial returns.

They want to know what their money is financing.

Could the index influence corporate behaviour?

The impact of the index could eventually extend beyond investment products.

If ETFs and index funds tracking the benchmark gain scale, companies could have an incentive to improve their business practices to meet the eligibility criteria.

This is similar to the broader idea behind ESG investing, where investor preferences can influence corporate behaviour through the allocation of capital.

STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD

The scale of that impact will depend on the amount of money that eventually flows into products linked to the Ahimsa Index.

For now, the market is still at an early stage.

The index itself is only a benchmark. Asset managers will need to launch products around it, and investors will need to demonstrate sustained demand.

There could also be opportunities for trading products linked to the index in the future.

Periodic rebalancing could generate buying and selling activity as companies enter or exit the benchmark. If derivatives such as futures and options are eventually introduced, the index could also attract hedging and trading interest.

A niche idea with a potentially wider market

The immediate market for an Ahimsa-based index may be relatively niche.

But niche investment themes can grow when they are converted into simple, transparent and easily accessible financial products.

The Nifty500 Ahimsa Index gives investors a way to combine broad equity-market exposure with a defined ethical screen.

That is its central proposition.

It does not ask investors to choose between values and diversification. Instead, it attempts to create a framework where the two can coexist.

STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD

The success of the index will ultimately depend on whether investors are willing to pay for that alignment through dedicated funds and ETFs.

But its launch signals a larger shift in Indian capital markets.

The stock market is no longer only about sectors, size, growth or valuation.

Increasingly, it is also becoming a place where investors can express what they believe their money should, and should not, support.

And for the first time, one of India’s oldest ethical principles now has a formal place on the country’s financial market map.

  • Related Posts

    Why oil prices never spiralled despite five months of the US-Iran war – Firstpost

    When the United States and Israel entered into direct conflict with Iran at the end of February, energy markets braced for one of the biggest supply shocks in decades. Analysts…

    Continue reading
    PLI schemes drive ₹15.2 lakh crore exports, attract ₹2.4 lakh crore investment and create over 14.15 lakh jobs: Govt – Firstpost

    The Production Linked Incentive (PLI) scheme has generated cumulative exports worth more than Rs 15.2 lakh crore, attracted investments exceeding Rs 2.4 lakh crore, and created over 14.15 lakh direct…

    Continue reading

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *