A customer bought a discounted Best Buy open-box television labelled ‘Excellent’ for around $600, but its screen did not work; the retailer refused the return, and a federal court allowed parts of the lawsuit to proceed | World News


A customer who paid roughly $600 for a Best Buy open-box television labelled ‘Excellent’ received a set whose screen did not work, only to have the retailer refuse the return. The dispute has reached court, where a judge has allowed parts of her lawsuit to proceed. Sylvia Kemigisa bought the television in June 2022 through Best Buy’s Open Box programme, but it arrived wrapped in plastic and displayed coloured lines instead of a picture. The court said she may pursue claims concerning the packaging and return policy, while dismissing her consumer fraud claim without prejudice and allowing her to amend it.

Best Buy’s Open Box programme and ‘Excellent’ condition promise

According to the court, Best Buy’s Open Box programme allows customers to purchase previously returned products at discounted prices. The retailer categorises these items as ‘Excellent’, ‘Satisfactory’ or ‘Fair’, depending on their condition.Best Buy describes products in ‘Excellent’ condition as items that “look brand new—with no physical flaws, scratches or scuffs—and include all original parts and accessories (or a suitable replacement).” The retailer also states that such products will arrive in their original packaging or a suitable replacement.Kemigisa purchased an open-box television on June 13, 2022, which was listed as being in ‘Excellent’ condition. She received it the following day, but it arrived wrapped in plastic rather than its original packaging.When she attempted to switch it on, the television did not work. The court document records her description of the fault: “the screen displayed lines of different colours, and there was no picture displayed.”

Best Buy disputed the return, claiming the open-box TV had a cracked screen

On June 20, 2022, Kemigisa’s nephew, Fesali Kaidi, took the television back to the Best Buy store where it had been purchased. However, the retailer allegedly refused to accept it. According to the court filing, Best Buy employees “refused to accept the television with no explanation and ordered Mr Kaidi out of the store.” Kaidi interpreted their conduct as being motivated by his race.Later that month, the plaintiffs contacted Best Buy through legal representatives in an attempt to explain the situation and reach an amicable resolution. However, Best Buy responded in a letter dated August 19, 2022, denying their allegations. The retailer said it had refused the return because there was a crack in the television screen.Kemigisa and Kaidi disputed that explanation, maintaining that the screen had never been cracked and describing Best Buy’s reason for refusing the return as a lie. Best Buy’s return policy, as outlined in the court document, allows customers to return products, including Open Box purchases, within 15 days of delivery, provided they are in a like-new condition. It also states that returns may be refused for items that are damaged, unsanitary, dented, scratched or missing major contents.

Judge rejects Best Buy’s arguments over faulty TV packaging and return policy

The plaintiffs initially filed their lawsuit in the Circuit Court of Cook County on December 1, 2022. Kemigisa brought claims for breach of contract and violations of the Illinois Consumer Fraud Act, while Kaidi pursued a claim under the Illinois Human Rights Act.After Best Buy transferred the case to federal court, the plaintiffs sought permission to amend their complaint and introduce class-action allegations. Their proposed amended complaint sought to represent customers nationwide who had purchased faulty Open Box products and had been unable to return them.The proposed claims included breach of contract, breach of implied warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose, and violations of the Illinois Consumer Fraud Act.In its June 9, 2026, decision, the court said Best Buy had acknowledged that Kemigisa had stated a valid breach of contract claim based on the allegation that the television was not working when sold. The retailer nevertheless argued that she could not pursue claims based on the packaging or return policy because its policies had not been violated.Judge John J. Tharp Jr. rejected that argument at this stage of the proceedings, stating that the court would not conclude that the plastic bag in which the television arrived was a “suitable replacement”. The judge also declined to determine that Best Buy had complied with its return policy, explaining that whether it had done so was “a key factual dispute in this case”. The decision therefore allowed Kemigisa to continue pursuing her claims based on either the packaging or the retailer’s return policy.

Judge questions Best Buy’s alleged faulty product scheme

The court also examined Kemigisa’s allegation that Best Buy operated a wider scheme through its Open Box programme, selling defective products while misrepresenting their condition and subsequently refusing returns when customers discovered the faults. She alleged that the retailer promoted the programme through misleading representations on its website, social media and other advertisements.The judge acknowledged that these allegations went beyond an ordinary breach of contract and could potentially support a claim under the Illinois Consumer Fraud Act if backed by sufficient factual details.However, the court found that Kemigisa had not provided enough specific information to establish the alleged nationwide scheme. It also highlighted inconsistencies between her claims that Best Buy operated an institutional policy of refusing returns and her separate allegation that employees had rejected her nephew’s return because of racial animus. The opinion stated that she needed to provide more facts supporting the existence of the alleged scheme and clarify its nature.

Court dismisses nephew’s claims but keeps TV dispute alive

As a result, the judge dismissed her Illinois Consumer Fraud Act claim without prejudice, meaning she could attempt to bring it again with a more detailed complaint. The court granted her permission to amend the claim by June 30, 2026.Kaidi’s claims were dismissed with prejudice because he had not purchased the television himself and therefore could not pursue the contract, implied warranty or consumer fraud claims brought in the amended complaint.In its concluding order, the court stated that Best Buy’s motion to dismiss was denied insofar as it sought to prevent Kemigisa from pursuing arguments concerning the television’s packaging and the retailer’s return policy. The motion was granted with prejudice as to Kaidi’s claims and without prejudice as to Kemigisa’s consumer fraud claim.The judge also denied Best Buy’s motion to strike the class-action allegations without prejudice, following the decision to allow the amended complaint.Disclaimer: This article is based on information contained in publicly available court records. The allegations concerning Best Buy’s refusal to accept the television’s return, the condition of the screen and the retailer’s Open Box programme have not been independently verified. The court’s decision does not establish Best Buy’s liability or confirm the alleged nationwide scheme. All claims should be understood in the context of the ongoing legal proceedings.

  • Related Posts

    Washington husband charged after rubbing his hands, covered with burrito residue, on wife’s face during argument; wife immediately collapsed due to gluten allergy

    Washington husband charged with wilful poisoning as he was aware of his wife’s gluten allergy and still rubbed his hands on her face during an argument. (AI photo) A Washington…

    Continue reading
    Shawarma fight in Canada turns into racist attack: Montreal restaurant worker beaten up after customer complains about meat portion, jumps over the counter, asks restaurant manager to return to his country

    Wajih Kurdi said the attack escalated after the customer saw his wife in burqa. A dispute over the quantity of meat served in a shawarma platter escalated into a violent…

    Continue reading